Skip to content

Pittsburgh Pirates: Where Will Jeff Karstens fit in Upon His Return?

With all of the talk about how awful the Pittsburgh Pirates bats have been, it makes it that more impressive how well the entire pitching staff has performed since the season began.

Currently the Pirates have the fourth best team ERA (third in National League) at 3.26, trailing only the Washington Nationals (2.92), Los Angeles Dodgers (3.20) and Texas Rangers (3.23). It hasn’t just been the starters, who have been very well, but it’s also due to the fact that the Bucs have the best bullpen in the National League, posting a 2.41 ERA (third best in baseball).

With that being said, what is Clint Hurdle supposed to do with Jeff Karstens when he returns?

Karstens threw 45 pitches Monday — 37 in a rehab start with Class AA Altoona, eight more in the bullpen afterward — and reported no ill effects or pain. He allowed two hits in three scoreless innings. Karstens is scheduled to pitch four innings or until he reaches 60 pitches Saturday.

If that all goes well and Karstens nears return to the Pirates roster, who goes and what role does he fill?

You can’t really make a case for him in the starting rotation given the way the five current guys are pitching.

James McDonald, Charlie Morton, Erik Bedard and A.J. Burnett aren’t going anywhere anytime soon.

Looking at the bullpen, how do you make a case for anyone of : Jason Grilli, Joel Hanrahan, Chris Resop, Juan Cruz, Jared Hughes, Tony Watson or Brad Lincoln, not to be a part of the big league roster when Karstens returns? These guys get batters out and do it very effectively.

So while Karstens can pitch out of the bullpen, there’s no spot for him and carrying 13 pitchers should not be an option.

That leaves only one man for Karstens to potentially replace and that’s Kevin Correia.

Yet while Correia’s numbers suggest he’s a 1-5 pitcher with a 4.50 ERA, he’s been much better than that at times. You also have to ask yourself if Karstens gives the Bucs a better chance to win every fifth day than Correia?

That answer is probably a yes, but it’s not an overwhelming yes.

Correia’s career ERA is 4.60 while Karstens is 4.52. Both guys are hit-able, as neither have over-powering stuff. Throughout their careers, Correia has allowed 9.5 hits per nine innings and 1.1 home runs per nine. Karstens has allowed 9.8 and 1.3.

They are practically the same pitcher and while you can point towards Correia’s struggles the second-half of 2011, Karstens wasn’t very good in August or September either.

Basically that means the Bucs pitching staff isn’t getting an upgrade by adding Karstens back into the fold.

However the Bucs are loyal to Karstens and he’s done some good things in a Pirates uniform, so I would expect him to take Correia’s spot in the rotation when he’s healthy.

That would make a roster move necessary and Correia could likely be dealt. However don’t expect Neal Huntington to be able to get much for him and they definitely won’t be able to improve the offense in a Correia deal.

So while Karstens is working his way back to Pittsburgh, you have to wonder where he really fits in upon his return?

Follow City of Champions Sports on Twitter

Follow Matt Shetler on Twitter and Facebook

Pittsburgh Pirates Designate Nate McLouth for Assignment, Re-Call Matt Hague

The Pittsburgh Pirates made a roster move today in an attempt to spark the worst offense in the major league’s by designating out fielder Nate McLouth for assignment and re-calling first baseman Matt Hague from Triple-A Indianapolis.

It’s been a rough go of things since 2008 for McLouth, who in that season hit .276/.356/.497 with 26 homers, 94 RBI, 113 runs, 23 steals and an NL-best 46 doubles.

Since that season, McLouth’s career has been in a large downward spiral that culminated with him being DFA’d today.

After an awful 2010 and a pretty poor 2011, McLouth found himself back in Pittsburgh this season. And after 34 games with a .140/.210/.175 line, McLouth is now being purged from the roster.

It seems pretty likely McLouth clears waivers and accepts his assignment to Triple-A Indianapolis, as his career path goes from an All-Star at age 26 to minor-leaguer at age 30.

As for Hague, he’s not one of the top prospects in the organization, but there’s really no reason he shouldn’t get a long look as an everyday first baseman.

Given the constant failures of both Garrett Jones and Casey McGehee, quite frankly Hague can’t be any worse.

He’s a guy that has impressed with his bat during the spring and a player that manager Clint Hurdle should commit to giving regular at bats to, at least in the immediate future.

Who knows, maybe if Hague starts to hit a little it will be contagious to the rest of the Pirates bats.

Follow City of Champions Sports on Twitter

Follow Matt Shetler on Twitter and Facebook

Pittsburgh Power no longer in Command; P.J. Berry with another stellar performance

Down 37-34 quarterback Derek Cassidy dropped back to find wide receiver P.J. Berry for a touchdown to give the Pittsburgh Power the lead, or at least that was supposed to happen. Instead a referee close to the play ruled the ball incomplete and kicker Geoff Boyer missed a field goal later in the drive.

The Power would go on to lose 43-37.

“I knew he caught the ball,” Seigfried said regarding the ruling. “My understanding of what happened was the extra balls from the ball boys were up on the other side of the wall and he came down with the ball, caught the ball, still had it and stood up with it and it was a touchdown. It was a bad call.”

The Power now fall to 2-8 on the season and hand the Command their first win of the season.

Seigfried did not see any real positives during his post game press conference.

“Not really, maybe the kicker making extra points,” Seigfried said. “We let a team that didn’t have a win come in and beat us.”

A positive though may have been Berry, who despite the controversial drop, did catch 10 passes for 94 yards and two touchdowns. His first touchdown came in the first quarter gave the Power a 7-0 lead, one of two leads they had all game.

Perhaps his biggest play though was in the third when he was inserted into the defense on a fourth down play, and he made a pivotal interception.

This provided a short-term spark, as the Power scored on the next drive as Mike Washington caught one of his two touchdowns to give the Power a 34-27 lead.

“Anytime you get to play a position you normally don’t play,” Berry said. “There was a little spark there, but we joke all of the time in practice that ‘I can play DB, and they can play wide receiver’, but it’s very rare that you actually have a chance to do it. Ricky [Gary] went down, so they needed another DB.”

Bryan Randall got the start in this game, however the Power fumbled the ball numerous times once again and lost two of them. Randall has been the guilty party of many of these fumbles and his fumble with 11:04 left in the second quarter was all Seigfried needed to see. He was relieved for Cassidy who played the remainder of the game.

At the end of the game the Command recovered an onside kick and ran out the clock to assure them of the victory.

“It’s a tough one,” Seigfried said of the loss. “I think we have some guys in that locker room that are content just being on the team and that needs to change. It was just a bad day all the way around.”

Game Notes:

It was Kids Day at CONSOL Energy Center and there was an announced attendance of 5,062.

The Power are on a bye week this week and will face the Arizona Rattlers who have a 7-3 record. The Rattlers are the runner ups last season and had the best regular season record. They have the fourth best passing attack in the AFL.

The next home game for the Power will be Saturday June 16 against the Milwaukee Mustangs. There will be a monkey rodeo at the half. Kickoff will be 7:30 PM at CONSOL Energy Center. Tickets start $15 and $10 for Student Rush.

Kicker Geoff Butler may be the short-term answer at kicker. While he was 1-2 in field goals, he did make four out of his five extra points [one was blocked]. This is the most efficient a Power kicker has been since the departure of Collin Wagner.

The fact that Seigfried showed up for the game was somewhat miraculous. Seigfried was in a hospital all day with food poisoning and showed up at 6 PM, 90 minutes before kickoff. Defensive coordinator Derek Stingley had an increased role in the game according to Seigfried.

Scoring summary Pittsburgh Power vs Kansas City Command 5/19/12

First Quarter:

Power: Berry 4 yard pass from Randall (Boyer kick is good) 7-0 9:30

Command: Lee 5 yard run (Wilhoit kick is good) 7-7 5:08

Command: Robinson 5 yard pass from Gutierrez (Wilhoit kick is good) 14-7 4:01

Power: Washington 12 yard pass from Randall (Boyer kick blocked) 14-13 0:45

Command: Parks 27 yard pass from Gutierrez (Wilhoit kick no good) 20-13 0:00

Second Quarter:

Power: Berry 24 yard pass from Cassidy (Boyer kick good) 20-20 7:44

Command: Gutierrez 3 yard run (Wilhoit kick is good) 27-20 3:43

Third Quarter:

Power: Cassidy 1 yard run (Boyer kick good) 27-27 11:41
Power: Washington 18 yard pass from Cassidy (Boyer kick good) 34-27 4:07

Command: Chambers 8 yard pass from Gutierrez (Wilhoit kick good) 34-34 0:52

Fourth Quarter:

Command: Wilhoit 40 yard field goal 37-34 9:55

Command: Robinson 20 yard pass from Gutierrez (Wilhoit kick no good) 43-34 1:22

Power: Boyer 32 yard field goal 43-37 0:19

 

Game Awards:

Russell Athletic Offensive Player of the Game: Matt Gutierrez – KC

Riddell Defensive Player of the Game: Bradly Chavez – KC

JLS Ironman: P.J. Berry – PIT

AFL Playmaker of the Game: P.J. Berry – PIT

Cutters Catch of the Game: Xavier Lee against the boards – KC

Spalding Highlight of the Game: P.J. Berry’s interception – PIT

National Guard MVP: Matt Gutierrez – KC

 

American Conference- East Division Standings

Philadelphia Soul 7-3

Cleveland Gladiators 6-3

Milwaukee Mustangs 3-6

Pittsburgh Power 2-8

Recent Articles

15
May

Pitt Football: Paul Chryst Tabs Tino Sunseri Starting Quarterback

To the surprise of absolutely no one, new Pitt head coach Paul Chryst is sticking with veteran Tino Sunseri as the team’s starting quarterback going into fall practice.

Chryst said Tuesday during the ACC spring meetings, “He was the best quarterback we had out of spring. That’s why he’s the starter.”

After a brutal 2011 season in which he never really grasped the “low-octane” offense of former head coach Todd Graham, Sunseri gets a fresh start in 2012 under his third offense in as many years.

Sunseri threw for 2,616 yards and only 10 touchdowns in 2011, and also threw 11 interceptions while getting sacked an NCAA-leading 61 times. Despite the lack of production, there really wasn’t much competition for the job this spring, as Sunseri’s only competition was Mark Myers and Trey Anderson.

The move by Chryst is the right one.

A first-year head coach needs a veteran signal-caller, and while Sunseri will never be confused with a Heisman Trophy contender, he did show some ability in 2010 by throwing 16 touchdowns to only nine interceptions under former coach Dave Wannstedt.

Sunseri was not a good fit for Graham’s spread attack, but his primary problem through two years as a starter has been overall inconsistent play.

He can make a couple of good throws on one drive, then leave you scratching your head the next.

Pitt fans may not be happy seeing Sunseri under center for a third-straight season, but given the current roster he’s the only real option Chryst has.

That could change when heralded freshman Chad Voytik arrives for fall practice, and it will be interesting to see how much Voytik is worked in initially as Chryst has yet to name a backup.

The chance of Voytik being named the starter for the opener is slim, but if the freshman has a good camp it wouldn’t surprise me to see him worked in early.

As for now though, it’s another year of Sunseri under center for the Panthers. Hopefully for their sake he can bounce back and be a somewhat productive quarterback.

Follow City of Champions Sports on Twitter

Follow Matt Shetler on Twitter and Facebook

15
May

Pittsburgh Pirates: Should Brad Lincoln Have a Bigger Role?

The Pittsburgh Pirates starting rotation, and pitching staff as a whole, has done a tremendous job throughout the early part on the season so far, entering play on Monday with the second best ERA in the majors at 3.15.

A guy that’s been a big part of that and often goes unnoticed is former first-round draft pick Brad Lincoln.

Lincoln seems to have found his nitch in the bullpen, entering the Monday with a 0.63 ERA in 14.1 innings out of the Pirates’ pen.

But the former No. 4 overall pick in the nation showed his ability as a starter as well in Monday’s 3-2 victory over the Miami Marlins, improving his record to 3-0 on the season.

The win gave the Bucs a season high three-game win streak and pulled them within a game of .500 at 17-18.

But what should manager Clint Hurdle do with Lincoln long-term?

If he remains in the bullpen I would like to see Lincoln be given a bigger role and used in more important situations, but personally I’d like to see him used as a starter.

Sure he can fill the old role of Jeff Karstens and could pitch out of the pen and serve as a sixth starter when needed, but I feel Lincoln’s true value is in the rotation.

I’ve always been a fan of Lincoln’s and after some arm problems early in his career, he got the long-awaited call in 2010. But after some struggles initially, I don’t feel that Lincoln ever really got a fair look after that.

Eventually some tough decisions are going to need to be made when the young Pirates pitching prospects throughout the organization are deemed ready. That decision process can begin now by giving Lincoln a long look in the rotation.

He’s a much different pitcher now than what Pirates fans saw in 2010. Lincoln has much better command of the strike zone (54 of 80 pitches for strikes on the night), especially with his fastball and just throws all of his pitches with more confidence.

I’d much rather Hurdle give Lincoln the ball every fifth day than a guy like Kevin Correia.

Nothing against Correia, but there’s much more upside with a guy such as Lincoln at the moment. I would even favor Lincoln in the rotation over Karstens.

Through 162 games of the season, things tend to average out and I think you saw that last season with both Correia and Karstens. Given the choice I’d much rather have the live arm and potential of Lincoln in the rotation.

If he keeps pitching well, Hurdle is going to have to address the matter sooner, rather than later.

Hopefully he makes the right choice.

Follow City of Champions Sports on Twitter

Follow Matt Shetler on Twitter and Facebook

12
May

Pittsburgh Pirates: Should the Bucs be Worried about Joel Hanrahan?

When the Pittsburgh Pirates shipped Nyjer Morgan and Sean Burnett to the Washington Nationals for Lastings Milledge and Joel Hanrahan in June of 2009, you couldn’t have found a happier Pirates fan than me.

Morgan and Burnett were no parts of the Pirates future and while I liked taking a chance on the upside of Milledge, I absolutely loved acquiring Hanrahan.

During that spring, the unproven Hanrahan caught my eye as Davey Johnson turned to him late in games for Team USA in the World Baseball Classic. At the time he seemed just like the type of power arm with a future the Bucs needed.

Looking back at the deal, it’s a win for general manager Neal Huntington as he would likely deal Morgan and Burnett for just Hanrahan ten times out of ten in the future.

Hanrahan had a successful 2010 season, he struck out 100 batters in 69 2/3 innings and became the Pirates’ closer at the end of the season; but came of age in 2011 when he  garnered a career high 40 saves, and finished the year with a 1.83 ERA.

He’s jumped right back into success in 2012 as Hanrahan has converted six of seven save opportunities, with the National League hitting a meager .156 off of him.

But despite the success, is it time to worry about “The Hammer?”

I’ve always been a big supporter of the Hammer.  I like the way he attacks hitters and it’s hard to argue with the results, but something is different with him this season; especially when it comes to his control and that alone is something to keep an eye on.

Hanrahan throws two pitches exclusively: a four-seemed fastball (96-99 mph) and a slider in the upper 80s. His fastball is his primary pitch, and the one he throws most often in every count.

That’s fine as long as the results are there, but way too often he can’t get the fastball over the plate. When he does, opposing hitters can’t catch up to it consistently.

But he must start painting the strike zone with it more consistently.

Also that once nasty slider hasn’t looked so nasty this season.

It’s another pitch he hasn’t been able to find the strike zone with consistently and throws it less and less per game.  When he’s going good Hanrahan’s slider is a weapon. Right now it’s not.

It’s definitely something worth keeping an eye on in the upcoming weeks.

Should the Hammer still be the Bucs closer? Absolutely.

You can’t argue with the results even though he’s making things more and scarier by the appearance. The bottom line is that Hanrahan’s getting the job done.

However, the control needs to get better or down the road Pirates manager Clint Hurdle could be forced to make some tough decisions.

Pitchers change and right now, Hanrahan is trending in the wrong direction. Hopefully when he returns to the team next week the break will have done him some good as for the Pirates to compete, they will need the Hammer at his absolute best.

Follow City of Champions Sports on Twitter

Follow Matt Shetler on Twitter and Facebook


 

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.